Which kind of squash makes the best homemade pumpkin pie?

So, about that canned pumpkin you buy every year…

It’s not actually pumpkin. Well, probably not anyway.

The truth is most canned pumpkin is actually squash. Legally, the FDA makes no distinction between pumpkin and squash when it comes to food labels, and so most canned foods companies opt to process the more flavorful and space-efficient squash instead of pumpkin and figure we’ll be none the wiser.

I’m ok with that, simply because squash makes for a better pumpkin pie than pumpkin does. If you’ve ever tried actual pumpkin puree you’ll know what I mean, it’s not nearly as flavorful, and is often stringy and watery.

I’ve played with making my own homemade pumpkin puree for pies before, but this year I wanted to test and see, once and for all, which type of squash makes the best pumpkin pie.

Banana, Honeynut, Kabocha, or Fairytale: Which kind of squash makes the best pumpkin pie?

I picked up a few different kinds of squashes from the grocery and our local farmers market. This time of year our market is filled with literally hundreds of different kinds of pumpkins, squashes, and gourds as far as the eye can see. I questioned the farmers as to what they would recommend for pie, and more than one directed me to the uniquely shaped Pink Banana… it’s definitely the oddest looking squash of the lot, and one I’ve actually cooked with before (so its recommendation didn’t come as a surprise this time).

I ended up with 4 squashes to test: Honeynut, Kabocha, Pink Banana, and Fairytale. Only the last one is actually a pumpkin, all the others are technically squashes. But again, no legal distinction and what have you so we’re calling the end result pumpkin pie no matter what. Because, let’s face it, squash pie just doesn’t sound as appealing.

Which variety of squash makes the best pumpkin pie?

To begin with, I roasted all the squashes until soft, then pureed them in a food processor (some required draining as well to achieve a mostly uniform consistency). Considering some of these squashes are rather large, I measured out the resulting puree into 15 ounce bags (equivalent to one can of pumpkin) and froze what I wasn’t going to use. Homemade pumpkin puree freezes beautifully, so if you’ve got a larger squash on your hands, definitely don’t let it go to waste.

Generally, about 2 pounds of squash will yield 1 cup (8 ounces) of puree, so you need about 3 pounds of squash for one full size pie.

I used Bravetart’s pumpkin pie recipe (which actually calls for butternut squash) as my base, and simply swapped out the different squash purees. I also made one pie with Libby’s canned pumpkin as a control, because I think that’s what all of us expect as far as flavor and texture goes.

From there, we were able to taste test and compare the one variable that changed from pie to pie: the squash.

The best pumpkin pie is actually made with... squash? Yup! Why not try this completely from-scratch recipe for yourself!

Ok, enough chatter. I know you’re all wondering…

Which cucurbita reigns supreme?

Which kind of squash makes the best pumpkin pie?

The Verdict?

Taylor and I meticulously tasted each pie, as well as our neighbor Richard who so unselfishly lent us his tastebuds. While I knew which pie was which (based on color and the unique crust I put on each one), neither of them did. Very scientific-like. Surprisingly, we all unanimously agreed on our favorites and least favorites.

The winners were definitely the Honeynut and Pink Banana squashes. Both were flavorful, with sweet notes of fresh pumpkin and a creamy overall texture. I may end up making my final Thanksgiving pie with a mixture of both for this reason. If you can’t find honeynut, butternut will do as well (though it won’t be quite as flavorful or sweet).

Our least favorites were the Kabocha and Fairytale, for different reasons. The kabocha simply produced a dry and pasty pie. If it had been super flavorful, it might have worked with an adapted recipe, but as it was it didn’t taste like much of anything. The Fairytale also had an unappealing texture on the opposite end of the spectrum; this pie had a watery and almost curdled consistency. The taste was also noticeably vegetal, like a raw, uncooked pumpkin smells. Long story short: keep the fairytale pumpkin on the porch by your mums: it’s better for decoration than for eating.

Kabocha vs Fairytale: Which variety of squash/pumpkin makes the best pumpkin pie?

You can see the obvious differences in textures between the different varieties. The thick yellow puree on the left is from the kabocha squash, and the orange one on the right is the stringier, waterier fairytale pumpkin (this one strained off nearly half its volume in water!) It’s a marked difference that is apparent in the final pie too. (Totally unintentional that this photo happened to be of the two kinds we didn’t like).

Cats like squash too.

The honeynut and banana squashes, on the other hand, fell somewhere in the middle in terms of moisture/creaminess. The banana definitely drained off more liquid (the honeynut only a few tablespoons, you could probably skip that step) but they both had a wonderful texture that proved perfect for pie.

From top to bottom: Kabocha, Pink Banana, Fairytale, Honeynut, and Libby’s (ignore the Sgt. Pepper photobomb – he LOVES squash and wouldn’t leave me alone for one second while I was shooting them).

Which kind of squash makes the best pumpkin pie?

Tasting notes:

Honeynut: (Pictured above). Sweet and flavorful, this one probably came the closest to the Libby’s pie in terms of texture and color, but with a brighter, fresher flavor. The honeynut puree didn’t need very much draining (it only gave off a few tablespoons of liquid, so you could probably skip this step entirely). This pie was noticeably sweeter in flavor and darker orange in color than the other kinds, more like what you’d expect from a classic pumpkin pie recipe.

Pink Banana: Our other favorite, this giant squash made a beautifully creamy pie with just the right amount of fresh pumpkin flavor. It was lighter in color than the honeynut, with a milder squash flavor that allowed more of the spice to come through. This squash is more watery than the honeynut, so I’d definitely advise draining it overnight before using the puree.

Kabocha: This squash had an entirely different texture than the others. It was much denser, drier, and not stringy at all. When I made the puree I was optimistic for this reason, but the final pie was noticeably pasty and dry and, well, not appealing in the least. It also didn’t have much flavor. Bummer.

Fairytale: This pumpkin was really watery and stringy. I don’t know if a smaller one would’ve been better, but we weren’t fans of the final texture or the odd vegetal flavor of the pie. This pie tasted like a fresh cut pumpkin smells, which wasn’t necessarily a good thing. The pink color was also a bit weird too.

Libby’s: I have a feeling Libby’s cooks their pumpkin longer, since the flavor is much more concentrated and almost roasty. I think you could maybe replicate this by stewing or roasting your pumpkin puree further after making it. Typically, I’ve found other brands of canned pumpkin to be milder in flavor and I prefer them over Libby’s (including Whole Foods Organic Pumpkin Puree and Trader Joe’s pumpkin puree). Maybe those two are actually pumpkin? We may never know.

Which kind of squash makes the best pumpkin pie?

For those of you interested in the pie recipe itself, I won’t be posting it here, but definitely check out the Bravetart cookbook where you can find both the filling and crust recipes. It’s easily my new favorite baking cookbook. Her pie crust comes together more like a laminated pastry dough instead of a typical pie crust, with a higher proportion of butter and thus less worry about developing gluten. As a result, it’s much easier to work with than many pie doughs I’ve tried.

The pie itself is quite good, perfectly custardy in texture, albeit a bit sweet for my tastes. It calls for homemade sweetened condensed milk as well as homemade squash puree (that’s right, no can opener is required for this pie! I love that.)

Next time, I’d still do the condensed milk but either with less sugar, or I’d leave out the extra 1/4 cup of brown sugar that is added in later. I’d also probably reduce the ginger a bit because Taylor, for whatever reason, is ultra sensitive to ginger (I think I’ve overdone it on the ginger before, most likely. ha!)

Recipe taste test: Which kind of squash makes the best pumpkin pie?

And no, I did not actually bake 5 full size pumpkin pies (that would’ve been ridiculous). Rather, I baked one 7-inch pie and four baby 5-inch pies using mini pie tins. The 7-inch pie is exactly half of a 9-inch pie, and the mini ones are about 1/6 of a recipe if you do the math, though more like 1/8 when you take into account the volume of the crust. It worked out quite perfectly, as I made one full pie recipe and it divided up almost perfectly into my 5 pies.

Who would’ve thought all that middle school math (ratios and fractions and proportions) and science (setting a control and variables) would come in so handy (I remember thinking way back then, when will I ever use this?) Maybe middle school teachers need to incorporate more pie and fewer pie charts into their lesson plans.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

That's My Jam: Four Seasons BUNDLE and save!

12 Comments Leave a Comment »

  1. This was SO much work for you! Omg…first finding and carrying all those heavy squashes, cleaning them, roasting them, pureeing them, draining, freezing extra, making pie crust, making pies…WOW and thank you!

    I have never heard of pink banana! I wonder what honey nut would be like on it’s own, not in a pie, just for roasting. I need to find one and try. I love sweet squash :) On it’s own kabocha is pretty sweet to me but I’ve never made a pie with it. Knowing it’s texture can be thick and definitely dry, I guess it’s not good for pies.

    Sgt. Pepper is adorable and I love that he loves squash!

    • I actually used the honeynut for the cider roast chicken recipe I posted a few weeks ago… and it’s amazing! That’s where I first discovered it, and thought to myself it’d make a great pie. :)

  2. Love the scientific method that went into this post. :) The honeynut squashes look similar in size to a butternut squash, right? I’ve always steered clear of some of the intimidating looking squash (like the pink banana and kobucha) just because they are hard to cut into. Maybe I need better knives.
    My cat is probably the only cat on the planet who won’t eat squash. The vet said she’d love it. Nope. She wouldn’t have any of it. Little weirdo.

    • Honeynut is actually a smaller, sweeter version of a butternut. It’s darker in color and maybe 6″ in size. A butternut wouldn’t have quite as concentrated a flavor or sweetness, but would probably be the best substitute in this case!

      And yes, bigger squashes are tricky to cut. A hammer and chisel is often the best tool, lol.

  3. I’ve made my own puree from Sugar Pie pumpkins, Bon Bon squash and butternut. Frankly, none of them rose to the level of good ole Libby’s Libby’s Libby’s. If I could dramatically improve on the canned standard, I’d be willing to do the work. But I couldn’t. And it seems like you could not either. But I am intrigued about the honey nut. That might be a good squash for eating.

    I’ve tried Whole Paycheck totally organic pumpkin and even it isn’t as good as Libby’s.

    As for Libby’s, they use a variety called Dickinson pumpkin, which could be called squash but is a very close cousin of the pumpkin. The Dickinson pumpkin was developed by Libby’s, which makes 90 percent of filling used in pumpkin dishes in the U.S. And It’s a winner.

    Very fun post.

    • I think if you’re used to Libby’s then fresh squash definitely isn’t going to taste the same no matter what kind you use, it’s a lighter, fresher flavor overall, not as rich and roasty. Same for other brands of canned pumpkin (which I’m guessing are using different varieties of squash/pumpkin). A matter of personal preference I guess. :)

      Have you ever seen Dickinson pumpkins anywhere? Libby’s probably keeps a tight wrap on them, lol.

  4. I have seen the seeds for Dickinson offered for sale at Baker Creek and Park Seed.

    Your post inspired me to do a tiny bit of web searching and I read that botanists say it’s difficult to differentiate between pumpkins and squash because there’s no botanical definition for pumpkins.

    Who knew?

    And I love the photobomb by your kitty!

  5. I first saw those honey nut a few years ago at Blue Hill Stone Barn restaurant in upstate NY! I definitely need to get my hand on one of those pink bananas though – I haven’t seen those in Chicago, but maybe I need to check out more farmer’s markets. This was such a fun post!

  6. I’ve had good success cooking and pureeing a sugar pie pumpkin for baked goodies. As I understand it is specifically breed for this. I freeze the leftovers in 1/2 cup increments so that I can defrost just the amount I need for muffins etc.

  7. Interesting comparison! I roasted squash and made the condensed milk for Stella’s pie recipe this weekend. I used butternut squash; I’m glad to hear that it sounds like the right choice. (Honeynut squash wasn’t available.) I’m also grateful for the pie review. The pie recipe is available on Serious Eats, and a reviewer there also said it was too sweet. The condensed milk itself has more sugar than my previous favorite pumpkin pie recipe, so adding additional brown sugar seemed excessive. I’ll reduce it, or perhaps leave it out altogether.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *