Love and Olive Oil

The Pumpkin Pie Incident

Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie

Ok, so the final product might look fine. But you have no idea what it took to get to this point. A series of disasters the day before thanksgiving forced me to wake up on Thursday morning and bake a whole new pie early in the morning, before we had to put the turkey in the oven.

Take 1: Pre-made pie crust. Yes, I admit, I bought a premade pie crust. I battle with pie crusts, and figured might as well take it easy on myself this year. Took the roll out of the freezer and let it thaw, then unrolled it and draped it in my pie pan. It was only then (and not at the grocery store where I should have noticed), that this pie crust was made for a 9″ pie pan. My pie pans are 9.5″. Failure #1. Any attempt at stretching the overly-sticky crust only caused it to tear. Into the trash it went.

Take 2: Cookie pie crust. Lucky for me, I had seen a recipe earlier in the day for a chocolate chip cookie pie crust. I thought, it’s perfect! It sounds delicious, and it doesn’t require rolling. Sounds like my dream pie crust.

Not so fast.

Pumpkin Pie FAIL

Oh the horror!

We all watched in horror as the pie baked, and the crust kept getting bigger and bigger and the pie kept getting smaller and smaller. Not only that but the little center of pie filling that was left was completely soupy, it didn’t even begin to set even after well over an hour in the oven. So we gave up. And at that point it was 10:30 at night and I wasn’t about to start over again.

(Just a note that I WILL be trying this crust again. The concept of it is too delicious not to. But maybe I’ll skip the baking soda. That just *might* have had something to do with the mutant crust that came out of the oven…)


Take 3: Woke up the next morning, and told myself to keep it simple. Used a basic pie crust recipe, and a soy version of the pie filling on the back of the Libby’s pumpkin can. It doesn’t get any more simple than that.

Pumpkin Pie Crust

Aside from some slight shrinkage when parbaked, this just might be the prettiest pie crust I’ve ever made. It did get a little soggy on the bottom underneath the filling, but overall a success.

As for the soy version, I do feel that substituting thickened soy milk for evaporated milk or cream in a pie recipe results in a slightly softer pie than you may be used to. It’s still delicious and doesn’t affect the flavor at all, but something about real dairy milk helps the pie set up. Which could have been part of the problem with my first version, who knows. But it works in a pinch.

I’m going to post the mish-mashed recipe I ended up using here, mainly for my own reference when I try to improve it next year. I’ve decided I need some more practice, and will probably try to make at least a handful of pumpkin pies and pie crusts throughout the year (which I’m sure Taylor will love – he’s the one always trying to sneak a bakery pie into the cart at kroger).

Pumpkin Pie

Makes 1 9.5 inch pie. Recipe adapted from Fine Cooking and LIBBY’S Famous Pumpkin Pie.

Did you make this recipe?


1/2 teaspoon salt
1-1/2 cups (6-3/4 oz.) unbleached all-purpose flour
10 tablespoons (5 oz.) cold unsalted butter, cut into 1-inch pieces

1/4 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar, packed
1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
2 large eggs
1 can pure pumpkin (not pumpkin pie filling)
1 1/4 cup thickened soymilk (water mixed with soymilk powder until it reaches the consistency of, well, thick soymilk?)

Whipped Cream (optional):
1 cup heavy whipping cream
2 tablespoons packed light brown sugar
1 teaspoon ground ginger
1 teaspoon brandy


Make the crust: In a small bowl, stir the salt into 1/3 cup very cold water until dissolved. Put the flour in a food processor and scatter the butter on top. Pulse until the mixture forms large crumbs and some of the butter is in pieces the size of peas, about 8 pulses. Add the salt water and pulse until the dough begins to come together in large clumps, about 7’ll still see some butter pieces. Shape the dough into a 1-inch-thick disk, wrap in plastic, and chill for at least 1 hour or up to overnight.

On a lightly floured surface, roll the dough into a circle 16 inches in diameter and 1/8 inch thick. Transfer to a 9-inch ceramic, metal, or glass pie plate, easing the dough into the bottom and sides and then gently pressing into place. For a traditional crimped edge, trim the overhanging dough to 1/2 inch from the edge of the plate. Fold the overhang under and crimp decoratively. Wrap and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes or up to overnight, or freeze for up to 2 weeks.

Blind-bake the crust: Position a rack in the center of the oven and heat the oven to 400°F. Line the chilled pie shell with parchment and fill it with dried beans or pie weights. Bake until the sides have just set and look dry, 16 to 20 minutes (lift the parchment to check). Remove the weights and parchment and bake until the edges are light golden and the bottom is pale and completely dry, about 5 minutes. If the dough starts to bubble while baking, gently push the bubbles down with the back of a spoon. Let the crust cool completely on a wire rack before filling.

Preheat the oven to 425°F.

Make the filling: Combine sugar, cinnamon, salt, ginger and cloves in small bowl. Beat eggs in large bowl. Stir in pumpkin and sugar-spice mixture. Gradually stir in soymilk. Pour into pie shell. Bake at 425°F for 15 minutes. Reduce temperature to 350°F; bake for and additional 40 to 50 minutes or until knife inserted near center comes out clean. Cool on wire rack for 2 hours. Serve immediately or refrigerate.

Make the cream just before serving: Whip the cream with an electric mixer on medium-high speed until it forms very soft peaks, about 2 minutes. Add the sugar, ginger, and brandy and continue whipping until it forms medium-firm peaks, about 30 seconds longer. Dollop in the center of the pie, leaving a band of filling visible around the edge of the pie, or dollop on individual servings.

All images and text © / Love & Olive Oil

Did you make this recipe?

Let us know what you think!
Leave a Comment below or share a photo and tag me on Instagram with the hashtag #loveandoliveoil.

There may be affiliate links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Anyone know why my beautiful fluted edge may have separated completely from the rest of the crust which then proceeded to slump during a prebake?

    • Sounds like your crust shrunk, but the edge was stuck to the top of the pan, hence the break. You’ll want to be sure you let the crust rest and chill thoroughly, and when you drape it into the pan, be sure you don’t stretch it. And use a good layer of parchment and weights (I like using granulated sugar) during the prebake to keep it in place. Also worth trying some different pie crust recipes and techniques, you may find one that works better for you!

  2. Here’s a little tip I learned. Mix about 1/2 tbsp all purpose flour and 1/2 tbsp sugar together and put on the bottom of your pie crust before baking to avoid a soggy crust. Hope this helps you! 

  3. Hey there! I had the exact same overwhelming fear of pie crust and ALWAYS used store bought, until one day mt boyfriend’s mom staged an intervention. She’s one of these people who can just “whip up” an apple pie, plus both crusts, from scratch, in 15 minutes, without making any appreciable mess… and it always turns out perfect. She just uses the pie crust recipe from the Better Homes and Gardens cookbook, that red one that everyone in the world has? It’s the best, and now my pies turn out perfect too!

  4. The cookie pie crust sounds great but I’m laughing at your description of it growing in the oven. It certainly looked interesting if not tasty. The final pie crust sure does look purdy.

  5. What is it about pie crusts!? I have a crushing fear of them as well, and when I told my grandmother about it this year (I figured she’d have a tip, since she bakes ALL of the Thanksgiving pies in my family), she confessed that she ALWAYS USES STOREBOUGHT CRUST. All these years I’ve been thinking she rolled out those crusts herself!!

    Still, I did successfully make my own this year!!

  6. What do you mean you cant do crusts – the one you made looks great! When I do pumpkin pie I dont blind bake the crust before, so it is even easier, just throw the filling into the crust and bake together. Also, have you tried the cooks illustrated pie crust with vodka in it? very easy, one of the best crusts I have made and I have made lots. Does NOT taste like vodka – cooks out. The article describes all the science behind it. see if you can find it on their website and if not I’ll send it.

  7. I had a pumkin pie incident this thanksgiving too…baking two pies at once didn’t work out that well!

  8. I’ve had my fair share of swearing and tears when it comes to baking. This looks beautiful!

  9. I appreciate your posting what didn’t work, as well as what did. I hope you are able to manage to re-work the cookie crust — it *does* sound good.

    I have my own pumpkin pie disaster story (from a few years back), involving substituting curry powder for pumpkin pie spice. Oy.

  10. About pie crusts and shrinkage — I believe that happens when you have to aggressively fit the dough to the pie plate. If the dough is just mildly coaxed into the nooks and crannies it responds positively.

    Seriously. Pie dough is such a diva.

  11. wait, you trashed the premade crust? say it ain’t so! you totally could’ve sprinked it with cinnamon sugar and baked it off into little cookie strips! a cookie pie crust is an awesome idea–the picture’s pretty amusing but i’ll bet it still tasted pretty darn good. the final pie is gorgeous–kudos to you for persevering!

  12. I literally LOL’ed when I saw the cookie crust. I almost woke up the snoring beast on the couch next to me! TOOOOOOOO funny!

  13. I know all about pumpkin pie disasters. When I was a kid I helped my mom bake. One Thanksgiving, I accidentally switched the sugar and the salt. So it looked perfectly good, but you should have seen my aunt’s face when she took the first bite!

  14. I LOVE the idea of using coconut milk! Will definitely try that in the next pie I bake. :) Intrigued by your hazelnut crust recipe too, sounds a lot simpler and fool-proof than regular pie crust.

  15. Hi,
    I’ve adapted the recipe on Libby’s canned pumpkin to use coconut milk instead of evaporated milk. It comes out great. You can check out my recipe here;
    I’ve noticed that you use coconut milk a lot in your baking, so you should definitely give it a try!


  16. Good for you starting from scratch and making such a good looking pie!

  17. Oh, I hear ya on the bad baking experience. And it seems on the day in question NOTHING will go right – the more you remake, redo, rearrange, and regroup, the WORSE things get!!

    I’ve finally had to leave the kitchen, mess and all, and come back the next day!

    The cookie crust is interesting. Definitely try it again!

  18. Looks yummy, I admire your commitment and courage in all things food!!

  19. The final pie looks delicious, so I hope it was all worth it in the end!

Did you make this recipe? Leave a Review »